Sessions: Justice Dept. Will Intervene in Campus Free Speech CasesSeptember 26, 2017 |
WASHINGTON — Decrying what he sees as political correctness run amok on college campuses, Attorney General Jeff Sessions said Tuesday the Justice Department will ramp up its support for students who sue universities claiming their free speech rights have been violated.
The complexity of the free-speech issue was on display as Sessions spoke to an invitation-only crowd at Georgetown University’s law school. About 200 protesters gathered outside in university-designated “free speech zones” and some students complained they were excluded from the Sessions event. Meanwhile, Sessions condemned the NFL players who have been exercising their own freedom of expression by kneeling silently during the national anthem before games.
“These players, with all the assets they have, can express their political views without in effect denigrating the symbols of our nation, a nation that has provided our freedom to speak,” Sessions said during a question-and-answer period.
In declaring free speech “under attack” on college campuses, Sessions dove into an issue that has become a cause celebre for conservatives who argue their voices are being drowned out on college campuses as speeches by right-wing figures have been derailed by protests and threats of violence.
Demonstrations erupted this week at the University of California, Berkeley, around a planned four-day conservative event dubbed Free Speech Week, which was suddenly canceled.
“The American university was once the center of academic freedom, a place of robust debate, a forum for the competition of ideas,” Sessions said. “But it is transforming into an echo chamber of political correctness and homogenous thought, a shelter for fragile egos.”
As Sessions spoke, the Justice Department announced it would throw its support behind a student who sued Georgia Gwinnett College, arguing his rights were violated when administrators limited where he could preach Christianity on campus.
The crowd of invited students, staff and Justice Department employees was mostly friendly. But in at least one row, students sat silently in black with duct tape over their mouths.
“We respect your views no matter what they are,” Sessions said in comments directed at protesters outside. “We will defend your views and the right to express them in appropriate and effective ways. We celebrate the diversity of opinion.”
Sessions hasn’t always been a vocal supporter of free expression. As an Alabama senator in 2006, he spoke out against flag burning, which the Supreme Court has ruled is free speech. He spoke then about the need for reasonable “time, place, and manner” restrictions on speech.
“In my view, the flag of the United States is a unique object, and prohibiting its desecration will not in any fundamental way alter the free expression of ideas in this country,” he said at the time, in support of proposed constitutional amendment outlawing the practice.
Ambur Smith, 24, a third-year law student who was protesting outside, said holding a speech about free expression but limiting the audience was “hypocritical.”
“He should be accountable to everyone in this country, let alone on this campus,” she said. “It’s a blatant contradiction of what it’s supposed to be about.”
But law professor Randy Barnett, who organized the event at the Justice Department’s request, said he invited certain students from his classes because he was looking for an audience that would be civil, not sympathetic.
“We did not screen people for political views,” he later told reporters, adding that the speech was livestreamed so more people could listen. “If they wanted to do more than listen and if they actually wanted to disrupt the event, then they were not provided with that opportunity.”