News

Opinion: Exam Winners and Losers

by Frank Matthews , April 23, 2009

Categories:

The New Haven firefighters case the U.S. Supreme Court heard Wednesday may have implications beyond employment practices. At the heart of the case are the murky issues of race, testing and selectivity – issues that are also unsettled in higher education.

A seemingly divided court heard the complaints of White New Haven, Conn., firefighters who did not receive promotions although they passed a qualifying exam. The city threw out the exams because no African-American firefighters scored high enough to be considered for promotion. Officials were concerned that the exam had a disparate impact on minorities, violating the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

“I certainly have sympathy for the plaintiffs but at the end of the day it was the wrong test,” Victor A. Bolden, the city’s corporation counsel, told The Washington Post.

Interestingly, a change in the testing criteria for admission to the University of California system is also raising concerns. The decision by UC Regents to drop the requirement that applicants take two SAT subject tests, also known as the SAT II’s, in content areas such as foreign languages, math and history, has proven to be controversial. Dropping that requirement will likely result in more Whites and fewer Asian American students being admitted, prompting the Asian Pacific Islander Legislative Caucus to hold hearings and demand the UC system to turn over documents justifying the change.

In California, a voter-approved affirmative action ban forced highly selective schools to rely more heavily on tests, to the disadvantage of every group except Asians. Now, UC officials say the new change, to take effect in 2012, will widen the applicant pool.

1
Comments posted here may be reprinted in Diverse: Issues In Higher Education magazine, and may be edited for purposes of clarity and/or space.




FEATURED jobs
Full Time, Tenure Track Faculty
North Seattle Community College

North Seattle Community College (NSCC) is seeking dynamic and collaborative individuals for Faculty positions in Business, Physics, and Visual Arts. These tenure-track positions will be generalists able to prepare and teach courses in their related field.


Enterprise Application Services Business Analyst
Ithaca College

The department of Enterprise Application Services within Ithaca College's Office of Information Technology Services (ITS) invites applications for a Business Analyst position to collaborate with departments across campus to identify, define and document business requirements as part of Enterprise Application Services (EAS)...


Business and Economics Librarian
Cornell University

Requires: Familiarity with software and tools for information management. Excellent communication, presentation, and interpersonal skills. Must enjoy providing services to a diverse audience. Demonstrated initiative and flexibility, and ability to work independently and collaboratively.


Chief Information Officer
State University of New York

The State University of New York (SUNY), the nation s largest and most comprehensive system of public higher education, seeks a Chief Information Officer (CIO). This position is located in Albany, New York at the System Administration of the State University of New York.


Copyright 2012 © Diverse: Issues In Higher Education, a CMA publication.
Cox, Matthews, and Associates, Inc., 10520 Warwick Ave, Suite B-8, Fairfax, VA 22030