ACC, Maryland Exit Lawsuit Before NC Appeals Court - Higher Education

Higher Education News and Jobs

ACC, Maryland Exit Lawsuit Before NC Appeals Court


by Emery P. Dalesio, Associated Press

North Carolina’s Court of Appeals is hearing arguments Thursday into whether the University of Maryland will pay a $52 million exit fee for leaving the Atlantic Coast Conference. A ruling could take several months, and any decision could be appealed to the state Supreme Court.

The ACC sued Maryland in North Carolina, where the conference is headquartered, after the school said in November it is leaving for the Big Ten Conference. The university responded by suing the ACC in Maryland in January, calling the amount an illegal penalty. A Maryland judge has put the school’s lawsuit on hold until North Carolina courts issue a final judgment.

Coming court decisions will set the size of a likely financial settlement as well as help develop ground rules on financial penalties tied to shifting sports allegiances, said Paul Haagen, a Duke University law professor and co-director of the school’s sports law center.

“Exit fees are here. They’re here to stay and they’re here basically to prevent schools from capitalizing on their own short-term self-interest at the expense of the other schools in the conference,” he said.

The $52 million fee is the highest penalty ever assessed on a school for leaving an athletic conference and would be nearly equal to the school’s yearly athletic budget, Maryland’s attorney general’s office said in May. The school’s athletic department last year cut seven sports teams as it struggled with multimillion-dollar annual losses.

Maryland’s ACC departure is scheduled for July.

Maryland’s attorneys argue in court filings that North Carolina courts have no jurisdiction because the school is an arm of the state, and states enjoy sovereign immunity that protects them from lawsuits. The ACC’s lawyers dispute that argument, contending sovereign immunity doesn’t exist across state lines or in contract claims.

Related:  Bush Chooses White House Counsel Harriet Miers for Supreme Court

These are preliminary issues before courts have to decide the bigger issue whether the exit fee’s size is justifiable, Haagen said.

The ACC’s exit fee was around $12 million to $14 million before September 2011. That’s when the league announced it would add Pittsburgh and Syracuse from the Big East, which led the league to raise the cost to $20 million. The fee was raised again last September with the addition of Notre Dame in all sports except football. The revised fee is equal to three times the conference’s $17 million annual operating budget.

Maryland argues the increased exit payment provision adopted about two months before it announced it is leaving over the votes of Maryland President Wallace Loh and Florida State University is invalid.

If a settlement isn’t reached, the dispute could have a lasting influence by setting a guidepost on how athletic conferences can enforce unity, Duke University’s Haagen said. Courts will have to decide whether the ACC exit provision was set by estimating the damages to other schools when conference members depart, or is an illegal penalty clause, he said. For example, while a home construction contract with a builder can make the builder responsible for hotel bills if the job isn’t done by an expected date, it can’t seek to simply punish the builder with an extreme penalty, Haagen said.

“Here the amounts are very high. Is it really what the ACC and other institutions will lose as a result of losing Maryland in terms of scheduling, planning, damage to the brand?” Haagen said. “Or, is this an attempt to hold them in or punish them for leaving that has nothing to do with the actual harm suffered?

Related:  Perspectives: Immigration Policy Is An Issue of Morality
University of Louisville Sues Retired Professor Over Records LOUISVILLE, Ky. ― A retired University of Louisville medical school professor who writes a blog is being sued by his former employer after he requested records related to a ban on postseason play for the men’s basketball team. Media outlets report...
Ex-Baylor Official: School Undermined Sex Assault Probes DALLAS ― The former Title IX coordinator at Baylor University said Wednesday that top campus leaders undermined her efforts to investigate sexual assault claims and were more concerned with protecting the Baylor “brand” than the students. Patty Cr...
Supreme Court Rejects NCAA Appeal of O’Bannon Case The U.S. Supreme Court will not hear the NCAA’s appeal of the Ed O'Bannon case, leaving in place lower court rulings that found amateurism rules for big-time college basketball and football players violated federal antitrust law. The justices on M...
CIAA Keeps Basketball Tournaments in Charlotte The Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association, overwhelmingly comprised of historically Black colleges and universities, announced Friday that it will not move its basketball championship tournaments from Charlotte, North Carolina next February in...
Semantic Tags:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *