News

The Ebonics debate: separating fact from fallacy

by Orlando L. Taylor , July 5, 2007

For the past several weeks, the nation -- and its news media -- have been engrossed in an on going and highly emotional debate on the subject of "Ebonics," a term used by some to define a linguistic system used by many -- but certainly by no means all -- African Americans.

In many ways, it is rather remarkable that any language issue could capture the attention of the general public or the news media for such a long period of time. Yet, the current Ebonics debate has done just that. Why?

Perhaps the controversy has received so much media attention because it emerged during the month of December, a traditionally slow news period. Or, perhaps, it is symptomatic of one of the nation's quintessential issues, which is how to handle race and linguistic diversity in a multicultural society.

The lightning rod for the controversy was a resolution passed by the Oakland, California Board of Education that advocated teaching African American children standard English competency by respecting the language systems they bring to school and using these systems as a bridge to teaching standard English. This reasonable goal of taking students from where they are to where they need to go has been depicted incorrectly by many as an initiative to teach Ebonics in the Oakland schools.

Some of the controversy was probably triggered by the language used within the resolution itself. To its credit, the Oakland School Board has since clarified its goals and intentions on the Internet (http://ousd.k12. ca.us/oakland.standard.html). In its clarification statement, the Board states that it is not advocating replacing teaching Standard American English with any other language, and that the Oakland Unified School District is not teaching Ebonics. It also has clarified that it does not view the language of African American children as being biologically based.

As we ponder the merits of Oakland's strategy to teach standard English, it is important to remember certain facts that are well documented within the sociolinguistic literature:

1 | 2 | 3
Comments posted here may be reprinted in Diverse: Issues In Higher Education magazine, and may be edited for purposes of clarity and/or space.




FEATURED jobs
Full Time, Tenure Track Faculty
North Seattle Community College

North Seattle Community College (NSCC) is seeking dynamic and collaborative individuals for Faculty positions in Business, Physics, and Visual Arts. These tenure-track positions will be generalists able to prepare and teach courses in their related field.


Enterprise Application Services Business Analyst
Ithaca College

The department of Enterprise Application Services within Ithaca College's Office of Information Technology Services (ITS) invites applications for a Business Analyst position to collaborate with departments across campus to identify, define and document business requirements as part of Enterprise Application Services (EAS)...


Business and Economics Librarian
Cornell University

Requires: Familiarity with software and tools for information management. Excellent communication, presentation, and interpersonal skills. Must enjoy providing services to a diverse audience. Demonstrated initiative and flexibility, and ability to work independently and collaboratively.


Chief Information Officer
State University of New York

The State University of New York (SUNY), the nation s largest and most comprehensive system of public higher education, seeks a Chief Information Officer (CIO). This position is located in Albany, New York at the System Administration of the State University of New York.


Copyright 2012 © Diverse: Issues In Higher Education, a CMA publication.
Cox, Matthews, and Associates, Inc., 10520 Warwick Ave, Suite B-8, Fairfax, VA 22030