Guillermo: New York Codifies an Orwellian ‘Tuition-free’ College Plan - Higher Education


Higher Education News and Jobs

Guillermo: New York Codifies an Orwellian ‘Tuition-free’ College Plan

Email




by Emil Guillermo

Here’s a word of caution.

When a politician uses the word “free,” have your hand on your wallet and one foot out the door.

Because, free — aka, gratis, cost you nothing, nada — doesn’t always mean free, especially when it comes to college.

New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo

And that’s why Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s program heralding a “first-of-its kind” tuition-free college to New York public places of higher education is definitely a “read-the-fine-print” proposition.

It’s not like the fine print on an airline ticket that essentially gives up many of your rights. Still, no one will drag you through the halls of academia, unless you’re protesting a right-wing provocateur.

So buyer beware, there’s a caveat worth a capital-C here. The fine print for Cuomo’s Excelsior Scholarship program reveals a free-tuition plan that definitely comes with strings attached.

Good deal?

Not if you’re poor and really need help.

Chances are, if you’re a student already receiving financial aid, the Excelsior plan actually gives you less money than you might expect. Excelsior is the “Hamburger Helper” of scholarship plans that will be added to any existing financial package. You may be already up to your allowable cap.

The biggest beneficiaries stand to be those from middle-class families making closer to the annual income limit of $100,000, rising to $125,000 in 2019. That’s not rich by any means. But these are the folks often short-shifted in aid packages. Consider the teacher/retail worker family combo that often don’t get what they need. For them, it’s Excelsior to the rescue.

For others, it may not be the boon they expect.

  College Football Obsession: Sending the Wrong Academic Message?

Who are the others? How about the child of a single parent working retail. The child’s gifted. The mother makes $40,000 a year. The child may get other benefits from existing programs. To the degree they already get benefits, Excelsior won’t help them at all.

But consider this last minute add to the plan, the big string.

If you leave the program within four years of graduating, any subsidies received become loans, and suddenly free is no longer free.

At first, it sounds reasonable. Stay and be a tax payer, living and working in New York. Or else.

But what if a job is available in California? Or if one wishes to follow love, or whatever, to wherever?

Where’s the advantage when the loan has fewer protections than the federal student loans the student would have used in the first place?

There are ways to make college free. You simply open the doors and give subsidies in funds so institutions can apply them as needed in a system where public schools go from K-12 to K-16.

But that would be considered too idealistic and way too radical a concept. Like Medicare-for-all.

Instead, of that easy solution, as is typical in public policy, we have to go from steak to sausage by codifying it the Cuomo way, adding some filler, and some ground-in catches.

And then we end up with something that looks and sounds better than it really is, and practically Orwellian.

But it’s hard to imagine New York politicians bragging: “We’ve made free, not free!”

  Associate Vice President for Student Affairs

Emil Guillermo is a journalist and commentator who writes for the civil rights organization, AALDEF at http://www.aaldef.org/blog.

 

RELATED ARTICLES >>
Idaho Initiative Helps Admit 20,000 Students to College BOISE, Idaho — The Idaho State Board of Education has announced that more than 20,000 high school students have been admitted to Idaho’s public colleges and universities. According to the board, this is the third year students with qualifying grad...
Handling of Sexual Violence Examined at Hampton U., William and Mary HAMPTON, Va. — Federal officials are investigating the handling of campus sexual violence at Hampton University and the College of William and Mary. The Daily Press reports that the Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights is investigatin...
Regents Detail Secret Harreld Meetings During U. of Iowa Search IOWA CITY, Iowa — A majority of University of Iowa governing board members have described under oath how they secretly recruited Bruce Harreld weeks before hiring the businessman as president, circumventing the Iowa Open Meetings Law, court records s...
Report: University of Kansas Women Faculty Still Minority LAWRENCE, Kan. — A recent report says women faculty are still in the minority at the University of Kansas, where they’re also twice as likely to resign from their posts as male colleagues. The Lawrence Journal-World says university economics profe...
Semantic Tags: