Court Rules Against DeVos in Loan Forgiveness Case - Higher Education
Higher Education News and Jobs

Court Rules Against DeVos in Loan Forgiveness Case


U.S. Education Secretary Betsy DeVos’ move to delay Obama-era protections for students defrauded by for-profit colleges has been dealt a setback by a federal judge who called her actions “arbitrary and capricious,” according to a CBS News report.

In a lawsuit filed by Democratic attorneys general from 19 states and the District of Columbia and former students who challenged the delay, U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss in the District of Columbia ruled Wednesday that DeVos’ actions were unlawful.

Education Secretary Betsy DeVos

The case centered on the borrower defense rule, which allowed defrauded students to have their student loans forgiven. The rule was to have taken effect on July 1, 2017. DeVos had argued those rules created “a muddled process that’s unfair to students and schools.”

But Moss, an Obama appointee, cited inconsistencies in DeVos’ rationale for freezing the rule. He said DeVos acted without conducting a rule-making process on whether to postpone the rules, and he scheduled a hearing Friday to consider next steps.

Department of Education spokeswoman Liz Hill said the agency was reviewing the ruling.

Massachusetts Attorney General Maura Healey, who led the lawsuit, said the ruling was “a victory for every family defrauded by a predatory for-profit school.”

Toby Merrill, a litigator at Harvard University’s Project on Predatory Student Lending, which represents defrauded students, hailed the decision.

After two decades to rapid growth, the for-profit college industry was shaken by the implosion of two major chains of schools that misled students with promises they couldn’t keep and left them with large amounts of debt they couldn’t pay. The Obama administration went hard after the sector, issuing regulations meant to increase student protections and police the schools.

In trying to delay the borrower defense rule, DeVos said the regulations were too broad and allowed for potential abuse on the part of students. She vowed to create a new system that would be more efficient and fair.

But critics dismissed the freezing of this and other regulations as an attempt by DeVos to promote industry interests. They point to the fact that DeVos has hired for-profit industry insiders to top position at her agency.

Rick Hess, director of education policy at the conservative American Enterprise Institute, would not comment on the legal aspects of Wednesday’s ruling, but called it “substantively an unfortunate decision.”

Hess said the Obama regulation “gives blanket forgiveness to students who may or may not have been mistreated or defrauded in any way, it puts taxpayers on the hook for potentially large payouts for people who were not misled and suffered no harm.”

“I think what DeVos is doing is trying to be a responsible steward who is trying to strike a healthier balance between protecting students and ensuring that taxpayers don’t get ripped off.”

Merrill said she hopes the judge will rule that the delayed rules must now take effect. If that happens, she said, students would win some important protections: not having to sign away their right to sue the school, getting loans automatically discharged if their school was closed mid-program and if they were unable to transfer their credits to a similar program, and being eligible for forbearance when applying for loan discharges.

DeVos also put in place a new system of compensating defrauded students for their losses. In a break with the Obama administration’s practice of fully forgiving student loans, DeVos in December rolled out a new tiered relief system, in which students’ loans are forgiven based on their earnings.

That practice was frozen as part of a separate lawsuit. It was uncertain whether the recent court ruling would have any effect on the tiered relief system.

LaMont Jones can be reached at You can follow him on Twitter @DrLaMontJones.

TRIO Programs: Paving the Way for Diverse Students in Higher Education Being the first in my family to attend college is not only a privilege, it's a wonderful honor and gives me a great sense of responsibility. As a first-generation college student from a working class family, college was the exception not necessarily ...
Students in Educational Limbo After Sudden Harrison College Closure College students in three states and five Indiana communities are scrambling to get their education on track and their money back, NBC affiliate station WTHR reported. Without warning, Indianapolis-based Harrison College closed campuses in Anderso...
Two New Studies Examine Student Loan Default WASHINGTON – Deanne Loonin, an advocate for low-income student loan borrowers and an attorney with the Harvard Law School Project on Predatory Student Lending, has a suggestion for the U.S. Congress in response to the federal student loan debt crisis...
Howard University Placed on Federal Education List Howard University is one of the most prestigious historically Black institutions of higher education in the country, but the operations of the school in the nation’s capital have long been troubled in areas such as budget, financial aid, student hous...
Semantic Tags: