Broadening the Definition of Diversity - Higher Education

Higher Education News and Jobs

Broadening the Definition of Diversity



by Angela P. Dodson

A new book examines the strategies of faculty to serve as “change agents,” encouraging diversity on campus.


Teaching a sociology class at Bowdoin College as a graduate student taught Dr. Winnifred R. Brown-Glaude a thing or two about diversity.


There, she introduced her students to “multiple perspectives” on the subject through readings. The student body of Bowdoin, a historic, small, liberal arts college in Brunswick, Maine, is more than 70 percent White, according to the school’s Web site.


In the end, she says that 90 percent of the students “actually loved the class” and found the experience enriching. A small but vocal

minority did not.


“I also had a small percentage of students who pushed back,” says Brown-Glaude, now an assistant professor in the African-American studies department at the College of New Jersey. “They thought, ‘Oh, we shouldn’t be learning about women of color in this class. This kind of teaching … doesn’t belong here.’”


Later, Brown-Glaude says, when she compared notes with colleagues at other schools, she found, “This kind of push back wasn’t unique to me, so when the opportunity came at Rutgers to direct a national study — to really dig into these issues much more deeply — I certainly … jumped on it.”


The professor had done extensive research on race and gender before becoming project director for the Rutgers Institute for Women’s Leadership’s Ford Foundation grant. In that position, she directed a four-year study, “Reaffirming Action: Designs for Diversity in Higher Education.”


The findings of the project are summarized in a new book, Doing Diversity in Higher Education: Faculty Leaders Share Challenges and Strategies, $26.95, by Winnifred R. Brown-Glaude (Editor), Rutgers University Press, (January 2009), ISBN: 978-0, 8135-4447-2, ISBN: 978-0-8135-4446-5.

Related:  Dori Maynard Was a Champion for Diversity in Journalism


The book is based on case studies from 12 universities and examines the strategies of faculty “change agents” working to encourage diversity on their campuses. Among the universities represented are Columbia University, Spelman College and Smith College, as well as several state universities. Faculty teams selected examples of diversity efforts from their campuses for the study.


Examples included a Caribbean writer’s institute at the University of Miami undertaken for literary purposes that has fostered diversity and a required course at Spelman, on the African Diaspora, that explores intraracial differences.


Doing Diversity argues that the voices of educators and scholars who advocate for diversity and espouse its benefits for education “are rarely heard in public.”


As a result, Brown-Glaude says, the debate over diversity is often hijacked by the opponents who keep the focus on race, instead of broader definitions to include women, ethnicity, people with disabilities and other kinds of differences.


“They tend to reduce conversations around diversity to quotas, which are then described as systems of racial preferences. These types of debates tend to lock us in to a back-and-forth tug of war, which really has not been productive.”


When advocates do speak, the book argues, they focus on the legacy of discrimination, rather than on the educational benefits of having a more representative, inclusive college population.


Brown-Glaude claims that the debate is stalled because it also focuses too much on “top-down” solutions, the policies of institutions.


“We tend to miss, we argue in this book, transformations for diversity from the bottom up,” she says. “This is where faculty and K-12 teachers come in. These are the people who have had first-hand experience with diversity or the lack of it on their students’ experiences and learning.”

Related:  University President’s Accomplishments Overshadowed by Scandal


On academic campuses, she says, “diversity work” — defined as any activity that encourages inclusiveness — is often not valued or rewarded, especially when faculty members seek tenure.


“We are really trying to change that,” Brown-Glaude says.


The work that is done is left to very senior, tenured educators, mostly people of color and women, though not exclusively, who are more secure in their positions, Brown-Glaude notes.


Even they face risks, however, she says, noting that one faculty member declined to be in the study because he feared that public attention would jeopardize support for his program.


“This kind of fear and the tendency of faculty to do this work under the radar is part of the problem,” says Brown-Glaude.


Brown-Glaude says she believes that the election of President Barack Obama as an African-American in the Oval Office will “make this work more difficult.”


“I think we are going to come up against the argument, ‘Well, how can you claim diversity is still an issue when we have an African-American as president? How can you say the plight of women is still a challenge when you have a female secretary of state?’” she explains.


She says those are “fair questions” that diversity advocates should address, adding that “our college or university system still needs more work with regard to diversity, and we still have to find ways to have that conversation.”


For one thing, she concludes, the global economy demands that students be able to compete, and diversity helps prepare them to negotiate the turf.

Related:  The Economic Divide at New York University


As a companion to the book, a faculty survey on diversity has also been commissioned by the project. For more information, contact: Sarah Fenstermaker, or John Mohr,

© Copyright 2005 by

NCAA Board OKs Anti-discrimination Measure for Event Bidding   INDIANAPOLIS ― The NCAA Board of Governors adopted an anti-discrimination measure Wednesday that would affect the way the governing body evaluates bids to host sporting events. The NCAA said the decision came during the board's quarterly...
UC Davis Chancellor Says Politics Driving Action Against Her SAN FRANCISCO ― The chancellor of the University of California, Davis says politics are driving a state decision to put her on paid leave amid an uproar over her service on corporate boards and the school's hiring of image consultants after campus po...
UND Eliminating 138 Positions to Meet Budget Allotments FARGO, N.D. ― The University of North Dakota plans to eliminate 138 faculty, staff and administration positions to help meet budget cuts ordered by the governor, the school’s interim president told state Board of Higher Education members Thursday. ...
Diverse Docket: Judge Dismisses Suit Against Alaska Career College A federal judge in Anchorage has dismissed a race discrimination and sexual harassment suit against Alaska Career College by a former therapeutic massage program student. Senior U.S. District Judge Ralph Beistline found no legal or factual basis f...
Semantic Tags:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *