Columbia University Seeks to Amend Legacy Whites-Only Fellowship - Higher Education
Higher Education News and Jobs

Columbia University Seeks to Amend Legacy Whites-Only Fellowship


by Jamal Watson

Doug Gross

Doug Gross, a recipient of the controversial fellowship in 1976, says he supports Columbia’s decision to petition to do away with the Whites-only requirement.

When Doug Gross was awarded a fellowship in 1976 to study at Columbia University’s prestigious School of International Affairs, he thought he had been selected for the award simply because he hailed from the Hawkeye state.

But as it turns out, Lydia C. Chamberlain, an Iowa native who donated her $500,000 estate to Columbia University shortly before she died in 1920, insisted that her funds be used to endow graduate and traveling fellowships for recipients born in Iowa who were exclusively “of the Caucasian race.”

“I had no idea,” says Gross, in an interview with Diverse. “If I had known, I never would have accepted it.”

Gross, a prominent Iowa attorney and former Republican gubernatorial candidate who faced off against then Governor Tom Vilsack in 2002, says that he fully supports Columbia’s decision to petition a Manhattan Supreme Court to do away with the outdated requirement that only Whites should receive the fellowship.

“I think they ought to change it,” he says. “It’s ridiculous to have this kind of provision in place, and it should be eliminated right away.”

Although Gross received the fellowship, he did not graduate from Columbia. He took a leave of absence and eventually dropped out, opting to earn a law degree from Drake University in 1985. For years, he served as the chief of staff to former Governor Terry Branstad before launching a failed bid against Vilsack.

In an affidavit submitted several weeks ago to the Supreme Court, Lucy Drotning, Columbia’s associate provost for planning and institutional research, lent her support to the request made by the fund’s administrator, JPMorgan Chase Bank, to do away with the Whites-only clause.

  Follow-up Planned to 1968 Race Relations Report

“Circumstances have so changed from the time when the Trust was established, that complying with the restrictions are impossible,” according to Drotning’s affidavit. “Columbia University is now prohibited by law and University policy from discriminating on the basis of race.”

Other parameters for Chamberlain’s scholarship included a stipulation that the recipient would not study law, medicine, dentistry, veterinary surgery or theology and a promise to relocate to Iowa for at least two years once they completed their studies from Columbia.

Roger Clegg, president and general counsel of the Center for Equal Opportunity, a conservative think tank headquartered in Virginia that opposes affirmative action and racial preferences, lauded Columbia’s decision but says that the time is ripe for all colleges and universities across the nation to take steps to eliminate all race-based scholarships, including those set aside exclusively for racial minorities.

“In my view, racially exclusive scholarships of all kind are illegal, and I think that the overwhelming majority of schools agree,” says Clegg.

In recent years, he says that he is encouraged by the steady increase of colleges and universities that have taken steps to do away with these restrictions.

“Almost always, they have agreed afterward to give consideration to members of all racial groups,” he says. “That, by the way, is all we seek. We don’t try to end the scholarship opportunity, but just make it available to all students regardless of race.”

When a scholarship or trust is established by a private individual, it’s unclear whether a university has the authority to change the guidelines. Since 1997, the Ivy League school has simply opted not to award the fellowship at all.

  N.C. A&T Becomes First HBCU Named NSF Engineering Research Center

“Columbia long ago ceased awarding the fellowships in question and does not follow gift conditions that violate anti-discrimination laws,” the university said in a statement. “It should go without saying that a university rightly known for the great diversity of its student body is as offended as anyone by the requirements of these fellowships.”

The trust is currently valued at about $840,000.

Slur Found at Grace College Dorm Prompts Hate Crime Probe WINONA LAKE, Ind. — A Christian college in northern Indiana says a racial slur found written outside a student’s dorm room is being investigated as a hate crime. Grace College & Seminary President Bill Katip says in a statement that the messag...
University of Maryland Gets $220M Gift for More Scholarships COLLEGE PARK, Md. — To help double need-based scholarships, the University of Maryland is getting a $220 million gift from the foundation of a billionaire alumnus whose own education was made possible by a scholarship. The university announced the...
Discussion of Affirmative Action Impact on Asian American Students Rolls On ATLANTA — A decision around affirmative action efficacy in higher education admissions still looms amid the U.S. Department of Justice’s announcement this year that it will investigate pending claims that Ivy League and elite institutions place quota...
Fantastic Five: Strada Grantees Look Ahead to Implementation INDIANAPOLIS — Last year, five minority serving institutions, or MSIs, each received $325,000 grants from Strada Education Network, formerly known as USA Funds, to close the gap between academic and professional success. Dr. Lorenzo Esters Adm...
Semantic Tags:

One Response to Columbia University Seeks to Amend Legacy Whites-Only Fellowship

  1. A University’s significant assistance in awarding a single-race scholarship has been prohibited since passage of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Title VI prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, and national origin by recipients of federal financial assistance.

    Marc Brenman
    May 21, 2013 at 12:23 am

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *