Supreme Court Nominee’s Students Find Him Demanding and Fair - Higher Education
Higher Education News and Jobs

Supreme Court Nominee’s Students Find Him Demanding and Fair


by Jamaal Abdul-Alim

When Erik Gerding, associate dean for academic affairs and professor at the University of Colorado Law School, found out that one of his colleagues at the school had been nominated for the Supreme Court of the United States, the first thing he did was call him to discuss security and advise him that journalists were roaming the building and asking students to “report on his whereabouts in real time.”

“I was struck that his first and overriding concern was for the welfare of students,” Gerding recalled of Judge Neil Gorsuch, President Donald J. Trump’s nominee for the Supreme Court.

Neil Gorsuch

“He didn’t want his potential nomination and the media circus to disrupt the classroom experience of his students,” Gerding said.

“When the vetting process heated up, I am sure he had many other things to worry about,” Gerding continued. “But he continued to teach. He worried about and helped arrange for another seasoned faculty member to be ready to teach his class should the nomination become a reality.”

Gerding said Gorsuch “demands a lot of students in the classroom and models how to analyze legal problems from all angles.”

Similar descriptions of Gorsuch are not hard to find among students at the law school.

“Judge Gorsuch was challenging and pushed students to think critically about ethics in our profession,” said Oscar Cobos, a University of Colorado Law School student who took a class on legal ethics with Professor Gorsuch last semester.

“It was critical that students be prepared for class as he liked to engage with students,” said Cobos, who is treasurer of the Latino Law Students Association and co-president of the Spanish Speaking Law Student Association.

“It didn’t matter if he agreed with you or not, he was open to listening to both sides of an argument and would push back on both sides,” Cobos said. “Listening to both sides is critical for a judge and I know Judge Gorsuch will do that at the Supreme Court of the United States.

“I may not agree with all of his decisions but I think his credentials speak volumes and know he will do a great job if he is confirmed,” Cobos said. “He will surprise people in a good way.”

When President Donald J. Trump disparaged a judge who issued an adverse ruling against his travel ban by calling him a “so-called judge,” Gorsuch stated that such attacks were “disheartening” and “demoralizing.”

Cobos said he was glad to hear Professor Gorsuch’s response but not surprised.

“He truly cares about this profession and it shows in his teaching,” Cobos said.

Gorsuch —  a judge for the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals — has been a visiting professor at the University of Colorado Law School since 2008. Gorsuch has taught ethics and antitrust law at CU Boulder, typically teaching one course per semester through the Thomson Visiting Professor porgram, which brings leading experts from academia, the judiciary and legal practice to campus to teach classes in areas of key concern for law students, according to the university.

Colorado Law Dean S. James Anaya said Gorusch “adds a great deal to the educational experience by adding to the diversity of experiences and perspectives of those who are in the ranks of those teaching here.”

Gerding said the nomination process will be a “fantastic teaching moment for students.”

“They will be able to see one of their own faculty members go through the most intensive scrutiny of his writings and philosophy,” Gerding said. “Any Supreme Court nomination is high legal and political drama.

“But the front page legal controversies of the last few weeks underscore how important an independent judiciary is in a constitutional democracy,” Gerding said. “We’ve seen just how much the law and lawyers matter.”

Gerding said the law school has had a number of community discussions or “teach-ins” discussing the immigration orders of President Trump.

“We are planning more events to discuss other major policy changes announced by the new Administration, and we will have a similar forum to talk about the stakes involved in the Supreme Court nomination,” Gerding said.

Jamaal Abdul-Alim can be reached at or you can follow him on Twitter @dcwriter360.

Support Needed for Mixed-Race Students Several years ago, when I was a graduate student and staff member at the University of Washington, I attended a Black Lives Matter rally and march on campus. When it was time for the march to begin, the organizers asked the crowd to split into two...
Amherst College to Use Mellon Grant to Develop Diverse Faculty As a recipient of a prestigious $500,000 grant from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, Amherst College will develop an initiative to identify and prepare students from underrepresented minority groups to become faculty in the humanities. The grant i...
State of the Union Address Omitted Key Concerns in Education, Experts Note President Donald Trump President Donald J. Trump delivered his first State of the Union address since taking office, calling the current era “our new American moment.” But he missed an opportunity for substantive conversation on the growing conce...
North Carolina Group Keeps College Goals Alive for ‘Dreamers’ SANFORD, N.C. — As a high school sophomore and DACA recipient, the connections Danny Rodas made through his mentorship program were invaluable to helping him understand the challenges he would face paying for college. Ricky Hurtado “I fir...
Semantic Tags: