Bill Maher Controversy Needs to be Kept in Perspective - Higher Education
Higher Education News and Jobs

Bill Maher Controversy Needs to be Kept in Perspective

Email


by

This past weekend, Bill Maher, host of the quasi political/entertainment program HBO Real Time with Bill Maher had renowned Black intellectual and ordained Baptist minister Dr. Michael Eric Dyson and rapper Ice Cube as guests.

They discussed the controversy that erupted on the May 31 edition of the program when Maher flippantly referred to himself as a “house nigger” in an interview with Sen. Ben Sasse (R-Neb.).

The senator had been invited to the program to discuss his book on what he sees as the increasing problem on prolonged adolescence occurring in American society. Sasse and Maher agreed on the issue and provided examples and suggestions on how to rectify the problem. Things seemed to be going well up until this exchange transpired between both men:

Maher: Adults dress up for Halloween. They don’t do that in Nebraska?

Sasse: It’s frowned upon. We don’t do that quite as much.

Maher: I gotta get to Nebraska more.

Sasse: You’re welcome. We’d love to have you work in the fields with us.

Maher: Work in the fields? Senator, I’m a house nigger.

Audience reaction was mixed. Some laughed while other simultaneously groaned. Sasse’s body language betrayed a visible level of shock and discomfort despite his stiff grin. Maher, quickly commented that “he made a joke” and proceeded on with the conversation.

Well, many people were not so ready to move on. Reaction on social media was swift and intense. Not surprisingly much of Black twitter went to town denouncing Maher for his juvenile antics and more than a few went as far as accusing him of outright racism. Some demanded that HBO cancel his program, while others felt that the incident was much ado about something relatively minor.

Within 24 hours, Maher issued an apology.

As someone who was watching the program when Maher made his comment, I will admit that I was somewhat blindsided by the comment. That being said, I was not enraged. In fact, I actually responded with a mild chuckle in the way that people usually respond to people who make comments that are inappropriate, yet not so totally over the top.

I know that it would be very easy, perhaps even socially appropriate to have taken to social media and express self-righteous anger over the transgressions of a wealthy White man having the audacity to use the N-word in a thoughtless manner. However, it is probably safe to say that many Black folk were not as outraged as they feigned to be about the situation. Yes, I think there were some people deeply engaged in a level of intellectual dishonesty, or what we refer to as fake outrage.

Yes, I have my issues with Bill Maher. His crass sexism, brutish Islamophobia, smug self-righteousness and annoyingly outright “ain’t I a devil. I am obnoxious because I can be” attitude leaves much to be desired. He can indeed be a jerk at times. That being said, when it comes to racial issues, while he misfires at times, he does frequently hit it right on target. He often delves into areas such as police brutality, systemic and systematic racism, White indifference etc., that most comedians, in particular, White comedians often do not dare to go. He does try to keep it as real as possible.

Moreover, who among us is perfect.

Now, let me make it clear, as some who is Black , a historian by training and over 45 years old, I am well aware of both the brutal history and the inherit power and pain associated with the word nigger. No word better reflects the oppression that we as people of African descent have faced. From a historical perspective, the word is one that is rooted in violence, humiliation, denigration, degradation and other forms of inhumane treatment. Indeed, it has been used by a number of White people as a physical and psychological weapon against us.

To be sure, some Black folk have taken the word and internalized it as a form of self-scorn and hatred. On the contrary, others have taken the word, neutralized it and used it as a term of admiration or endearment. Nonetheless, like a number of historically marginalized groups, Black Americans have managed to take the word and somewhat neutralize as and? redefine it, just as gay and lesbians have managed to take the words queer and dyke and turn them into a form of empowerment to the LGBTQ community.

I also agree with the notion that Whites should not use the word. To all those who want to cry foul or espouse the misguided notion of double standards and other indefensible sentiments, the truth is that the n-word has a hostile and obscene history in the White community. It has been employed with violence (as in the lynchings and murders of Black people), malice, blatant disrespect, intimidation and varied forms of humiliation. From a historical perspective, there is nothing ambiguous about its use. In the Black community, even centuries after its origin, the word has a mixed and unsettled history. Thus, ongoing debates in regards to its usage is understandable.

Without sounding too sanctimonious, the fact is that the Black community is being confronted with a number of issues and people who likely view and treat us like niggers whether we use the word or not. The Trump administration is cutting hundreds of millions of dollars from public education which disproportionately impacts poor and lower-income Black and Hispanic communities, gutting after-school programs, and working diligently to repeal the Affordable Care Act and replace it with the draconian Trumpcare. The list goes on.

While we need to continue to have healthy and robust debates on the n-word and other topics that affect our community, it is important that we not get too sidetracked from crucial economic, legal, social and issues that directly impact us on a daily basis. Failing to do so could lead to our overall detriment. We must keep our eyes on the prize for survival’s sake.

Dr. Elwood Watson is a professor of history, African American Studies, and Gender Studies at East Tennessee State University.

RELATED ARTICLES >>
How Faculty of Color Hurt Their Careers Helping Universities with Diversity With more than one-third of the nation’s college students being people of color, there’s increased pressure for universities and colleges to foster a more inclusive learning environment. Prompting protests from students and higher education advocates...
New Questions in NSSE Survey Spark Important Conversations A topical module around inclusiveness and engagement with cultural diversity debuted in this year’s NSSE survey, and the results prompted discussions around teaching practices. Every year since 2000, the National Survey of Student Engagement (NSS...
Professor Apologizes for Fiery Response to Muslim Student CINCINNATI — A University of Cincinnati music teacher has apologized for his fiery online responses to a Muslim student who was critical of Donald Trump’s presidency and talked about celebrating freedom and diversity. College-Conservatory of Music...
Colleges Wrestle with Issue of Using Students’ Fees for Controversial Speakers Katherine Kerwin didn’t like to see a portion of the student fees she pays being spent to bring conservative speaker Ben Shapiro to the University of Wisconsin. Kerwin didn’t agree with Shapiro’s criticism of what he said were attempts to chill fr...
Semantic Tags: