States with a small number of African American students tend to have higher high school graduation rates for Black males than those with large African American student enrollment, according to a report recently released by the Schott Foundation for Public Education.
The report, entitled “Given Half a Chance: The Schott 50 State Report on Public Education for Black Males,” based on 2005-06 graduation rate data, indicates that, with only a total enrollment of 796 Black male students, North Dakota graduated 89 percent of its Black male students. Similarly, Vermont graduated 88 percent. Michigan had the lowest rate with “barely a third of its Black male students” graduating with their peers, researchers say.
The overall national graduation rate for 2005-06 for Black male students was just 47 percent. Of the 10 most successful large school districts that graduate Black male students, Fort Bend, Texas, scored at the top with a graduation rate of 82 percent. Meanwhile, the lowest performing large school district was Indianapolis, Indiana, with only 19 percent of Black males graduating with their peers.
The report points out that this research “substantiates that graduation and achievement gaps reflect the differences in the quality of the opportunities available, not differences in students’ ability.” Officials also note that one of the goals of the report is to highlight the fact that some students are not given an equal opportunity to learn.
“The primary objective is to highlight that, in America, there is a huge disparity between the education and resources that are offered to Black males and those that are offered to White males,” says Dr. John H. Jackson, president and CEO of the Schott Foundation, who adds that the report includes data gathered from the U.S. Department of Education’s National Center for Education Statistics and Office for Civil Rights, state departments of education, and local school districts.
Table 1: Ten Lowest Performing States for Black Males
Lowest Performing States
Total Black Male Enrollment
Graduation Rates 2005/06 Cohort
45. New York
48. South Carolina
Among the findings, the state of New York had three of the 10 districts with the lowest graduation rates for Black male students. In addition, Delaware, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, South Carolina, and Wisconsin rated below the national average in graduating Black male students with their peer group.
The report also charges inadequate funding and unequal school policies – such as the over-classification of Black male students in special education courses, disproportionate suspension and expulsion rates, and under-classification in gifted and talented and advanced placement programs – for the country’s wide disparities in educating African American males.
A “National Summary” chapter of the report included on the foundation’s Web site states that the above classifications are important factors in analyzing the nation’s dismal graduation rates and academic progress among Black students. For example, 3 percent of Black male students are enrolled in gifted and talented programs, as compared to 7.6 percent of White, non-Hispanic male students. Similarly, although Black male students make up 9 percent of student enrollments, they are 20 percent of mental retardation classifications, according to the report.
These findings among others, officials say, indicate that African American male students are oftentimes denied the tools that would lead to academic enrichment and successful completion of grade levels.
“These are students who can learn when given the opportunity,” adds Jackson. “They represent the potential that this democracy is supposed to give birth to.”
Table 4: Best Performing Large Districts for Black Males
Best Performing Large Districts
Black Male Enrollment
Estimated Graduation Rates 2005/06
1. Fort Bend (TX)
2. Baltimore County (MD)
3. Montgomery County (MD)
4. Newark (NJ)
5. Prince George’s County (MD)
Many say that schools nationwide still have a long way to go to close the academic achievement gap. Officials at the Schott Foundation will promote nine focus areas over the next five years, which includes the monitoring of resources in states and cities with a Black male student graduation rate of less than 50 percent.
However, some states, such as New Jersey and Arizona, are making strides and graduate African American males near or higher than the national average graduation rate of 75 percent for White, non-Hispanic male students.
According to the report, New Jersey, Arizona, South Dakota and Vermont, in addition to Maine, Iowa, Utah, Idaho, Arkansas, and West Virginia, are the top 10 best performing states for Black male students. The report cites diverse student body and educational environments and adequate resources for promoting student success.
Table 3: Best Performing States for Black Males
Best Performing States
Total Black Male Enrollment
1. North Dakota
5. New Jersey
(Charts Source: Schott Foundation)
© Copyright 2005 by DiverseEducation.com
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.